Yanga-Mbiwa written off too soon?

More to come from this player.
More to come from this player.
It’s fair to say that Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa has lacked consistency on the field since arriving from Montpellier in January.

The Frenchman cost the club just shy of £7 million. The price tag seemed justified following the defender’s excellent 2012 season, in which he skippered Monpellier to The Ligue 1 title. Mapou has certainly found it difficult to maintain those high standards in England and despite having some bright moments in a black and white shirt, he has also had some forgettable ones.

Mbiwa was dropped by Alan Pardew in Newcastle’s 2-1 victory at Cardiff. This followed a nightmare 45 minutes the player endured during the previous game against Everton, a game we were losing 3-0 by half time. Mapou was replaced by Mike Williamson in the second half at Goodison Park and then Mike managed to keep Mibiwa out of the team against Cardiff a week later. I think to be fair it’s worth pointing out at at this stage that Colocinni was also very poor in the first half in the Everton loss too.

It would seem that a few people have already hit the panic button with Mapou and feel the player will not succeed at Newcastle. Those skeptics include his former Montpellier president Louis Nicollin who claims the player has made a big mistake in leaving France. Nicollin told L’Equipe:

“I’m sorry for him. I love him a lot. He has followed the advice of his agent and he was wrong to leave.

“Don’t worry, he’ll come back to Montpellier.”

The first argument that the optimistic would raise is that Colo had a very poor start to his career on Tyneside. What about Jose Enrique? Both players were under the microscope during thier first season in England and both looked they were unable to adjust the English game. Colo and Jose both knuckled down and proved their doubters wrong with complete transformations in their performances. Granted it took a relegation to get the pair to standard, but they stuck to their guns and both became pivotal to our return to the top flight and maintaining Premier League status the following year.

Jose left on a bit of a bitter note as we all know, but just look at Colo. Who would have thought that he would go on to captain the club when you look back on his performances during his first season with us. Alan Pardew has said before that Mapou has great leadership skills and the lad’s CV proves it. To win a League title as an underdog is a great achievement for anyone.

Mbiwa has had a slightly shaky start to his Newcastle career, but he is young and it does take time for some to adapt. I had a conversation with a fan who described the player as ‘terrible’.I have to say I feel that is slightly premature and I think we have a good player in Yanga-Mbiwa, we just need to be patient with him. I also believe it’s only a matter of time before he’s back ahead of Steven Taylor and Mike Williamson pecking order.

What do you think? will Mbiwa rank with Colo and Woodgate or Boumsong and Titus?

90 thoughts on “Yanga-Mbiwa written off too soon?

  1. Aussie…Been better the last couple of weeks in that too, I believe me an thee were the highest scorers in the last round of games…as I keep telling the young whipper snappers, it’s a marathon not a sprint 😉


  2. It is mate, Newkie blew his load early and has dropped off the pace 😛
    I did notice that you racked up a couple of good tally’s..


  3. Kim@67-Exactly. Our full backs are so average, but people keep drooling over them because they can run with a football. I was always told to let the ball do the work for you, but then I was a very lazy centre mid 😀

    But seriously, those two strolling back after their rarely effective (but nice looking) forays forward has cost us on a few occasions and will continue to do so. Until we have a solid CB pairing then playing two at the back is a luxury we can’t really afford. How long has it even been since we had a solid CB pairing? 10 years? 😥 😆


  4. I agree with Georgio, this side of never for a good defensive pairing, unfortunately Carragher’s probably right about it.

    Aussie@80Probably why he struggles to hang onto a lass 😉 😆


  5. Aussie-it’s a common problem, or so I am told 😆

    I seYour mind games are only showing how nervous you are mate 😀 I’m gaining on you again and miles ahead of you on the predictor league 😉

    If Mourinho had listened to my advice and not shafted me (keep Lukaku) I wouldn’t have had to rejig the whole side after the first week. I’ll be back on top in both leagues in no time!


  6. Newkie 😆 it’s only a problem for your lass mate.. I’m sure you still enjoy the experience 😆
    Keep dreaming with the fantasy league! 😛


  7. Richie-Cheeky feck 😀 I only struggle to hold on to the worldies, with normall service there is always plenty to hold onto, if you know what I mean :


  8. if you know what I mean 😐 *

    Aussie- Wise words mate, I knew your age/experience would be useful one day 😉


  9. Newkie, i have plenty of experience and advice to be shared around.. unfortunately most of the experience is bad and so is the advice :mrgreen:


  10. Georgio@82-Truth be told I can’t really either mate. Did Hughes and Woodgate ever get on the pitch together? That counts right? 😀


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green