Demba Ba or Andy Carroll?

Would you take Carroll over this man?
With Demba Ba now proving the doubters wrong and looking like he has the firepower to fill his shooting boots there is an argument brewing to suggest that perhaps NUFC should look elsewhere as a priority for strengthening the team.

Seriously, that is how good Demba Ba has been in the last few games!

After a slow start to the season, a slow start that the player admits to I’ll add, Ba has started show the fans at St James’ Park the form that his career stats suggest that he is capable of. This will inevitably raise the question of whether or not we’ve actually managed to replace Andy Carroll already, without the presence of that elusive second striker over the summer.

The stats show that Demba Ba has scored eight league goals in nine league games (or if you want to be more impressed it’s actually eight goals in five games, as pointed out by Richietoon). That is not a bad return for a striker and leaves Ba needing just three more goals in his next ten games for the club to equal Carroll’s Premier League haul for us last season from the same amount of games.

On the goalscoring front at least, we seem to have replaced Andy Carroll. What about the rest of the game though? Carroll was a player who could bully opposition defences with his physical approach. He’d be a constant thorn in the side of the opposing defence and would have to be watched carefully at set pieces. It’s worth noting that Joey Barton set up the majority of Carroll’s goals and that when Carroll left both his own form dipped as did the assist rate of Barton.

How does Demba Ba measure up on that front?

Very well in fact. Ba is not exactly a featherweight striker. He is only an inch shorter than Carrol and is just as strong. If anything I would say that Ba has more to his game, such as pace like we saw against Stoke on Monday.

I said from the start that bringing Ba would prove to be a great bit of business and so far that is proving to be the case. Sure there is the issue of Ba’s knee problem, but as yet there have been no signs of it making an appearance. In fact the striker has been injury free for some time now.

I guess the question I’m posing now is whether you would take Andy Carroll back at the expense of Demba Ba? I know damn well that I wouldn’t. I’m not being emotional in my judgement, as it would be easy to use that to beat the Gypo with. I’m not even using his less that sparking start to life at Liverpool as a comparison. I’m not even saying that we don’t need another striker still and I’m not even fussed about the money. What I am comparing is Andy Carroll for Newcastle and Demba Ba for Newcastle.

For me it’s Ba. He has more to his game than just being a battering ram and has the ingredients to be somewhere near a 20-goal a season striker. What are your thoughts though?

[poll id=”46″]

About toonsy

A lifelong Newcastle fan and current webmaster of this very 'blog who has the sole aim of creating a place by Newcastle United fans, for Newcastle United fans.

81 thoughts on “Demba Ba or Andy Carroll?

  1. Blackburn plan to place a hefty £18m price tag on Canadian forward Junior Hoilett, whose contract expires at the end of the season, in the hope of averting interest from Tottenham and Newcastle – Daily Mirror laughable that is looks like its wait til the summer get 1 free deal lmao 🙂


  2. ‘it would be easy to use that to beat the Gypo with..’

    Balanced grown up journalism is always so much more impressive when mixed with casual racism, n’est pas?


  3. Toon Chicken says:
    November 2, 2011 at 16:03
    Troy – tie one end of a length of rope around the motor and the other around your ankle. That way if you do drop it you’ll be able to pull it back in.
    Oh, and make sure you fill your pockets with lead, it really helps with buoyancy.

    Toon Chicken. You are a total Knob. The ultimate internet warrior posting garbage from the safety of your keyboard.

    Couple of good results and you think you’re great again.

    I’ll come back in 3 weeks when you’ve lost to Man C, Man U and Chelski, Ba hasn’t scored for 3 games and you are busy slagging him and Pards off whilst sliding toward lower mid table mediocrity.


  4. Letting my heart rule my head its definitely Andy, but the better player for us has been Demba so far.
    Im still bitter inside that we no longer have AC because I think that he could potentially be world class but 35 million isnt something to be sniffed at and we’ve used some of that to invest in some great players (ben arfa, cabaye).
    I for one was pleased when we signed Ba though because his record is phenomenal at every club hes been at and i was sure he’d be a hit although not for one moment did I think he’d be no. 9 material.
    He is continuing to prove me and others wrong though and I can only hope his form lasts a long time. 🙂


  5. @Andy

    Everybody has to play United, City and Chelsea so I don’t get where this myth has come from? We’ve not just had ‘a couple’ of great results either, we’ve had 10!
    My guess is we beat your team and you’re ever so bitter about it because we seem to be going forward for once instead of backwards.


  6. Carroll was one of the best strikers we’ve produced in recent times. I think a partnership of him and Ba would’ve been brilliant. That said, if only he actually used his brain a wee bit more.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green