January transfer window round up – a realist view!

A surprise January signing
Not one of us fans had the foggiest idea with regards to our club’s plans for this January transfer window.

Alan Pardew went and told us that we were signing a defender and that was all we knew. So what happened?

Lets be honest, we were expecting to lose one of our key players for big bucks – someone like Cheik Tiote or Tim Krul – players that keep us ticking along. On these blogs some of us even convinced ourselves that we could maintain our current course without them, some of us even had faith that they would be immediately replaced, some had nothing but concern for what January may have in store, and with Tiote being the name that is continuously linked away it was he who was at the centre of most of the speculation.

For me, Tiote is key to our play. He is our glue in that he holds us together. He’s a machine that swallows up the opposition and gives us real thrust and bite. Replacing him would be much harder than some think – just look around – how many other sides have a player anything like him? Priceless.

What we did not expect was the news that Demba Ba has a release clause in his contract – so kindly broken to the press by a bloke who has nothing to do with us – Harry Redknapp. NUFC did not move to deny that rumour and now we find ourselves with the very real prospect of our best striker since Alan Shearer leaving this summer on the cheap – unless we can get him signed up on new improved terms.

Meanwhile, whilst we all battled through the perennial links to defender after defender, we find the club moved lightning fast and completely unexpectedly to secure the services of Ba’s International teammate and Bundesliga goal machine Papiss Demba Cisse! A striker with an increasingly fearsome reputation spreading across the continent. Good work team! That leaves us all standing to attention and applauding the club’s hierarchy and we start talking realistically about challenging Liverpool and Arsenal for that spot in the Europa League next season.

Not out of the question after all, since we lost Steven Taylor to his nasty achilles injury in December it was obvious that Alan Pardew and his staff, backed by Derek Llambias, would be getting a central defender in at some point – so once that signing is made we are sorted – and with extra fire power up front to boot! Excellent.

So the final days and hours crept up on us and we sat gawping at Sky Sports News and News Now waiting for an image of our new defender to appear outside St James’ Park. We waited and waited and waited. Meanwhile, Leon Best had been given permission to talk to Celtic. What?! With Peter Lovenkrands off on a free in the summer and clearly not fancied at present by Alan Pardew, why on earth would we ship Leon Best out? Just when we are looking like having a bit of quality in depth up front we go and try to blow it! Whatever your opinion is on Shola Ameobi, nothing can hide the fact that he has scored once this season and is looking less mobile with every minute he spends on the pitch.

Getting rid of Best, whilst losing Lovenkrands this summer would leave us with only three recognised forwards for next season – with the two Demba’s off to the African Cup of Nations again at the beginning of 2013. Even if we signed somebody, that would still leave us with the very real prospect of having to rely on Shola for a good month next season. Not a wise move allowing Best to go at all. He’s cheap and reasonably effective, what have we got to gain by letting him go?

In the end he chose to stay and I for one am very grateful for that. So then, the days and hours have blended into the passages of time and we are still sat staring at the TV screens for some news – any news – about a defender coming in, whilst small beads of sweat trickle down our nervous little foreheads. Some debate ensues about Watford stopper Adrian Mariappa’s ability to come in to our squad and do a good job, not that it mattered – as that move came to nothing anyway.

Luckily for us, the window slammed shut with Newcastle United having lost nobody of note except James Tavernier and the fallen star that is Alan Smith on loan. In the end, that alone makes it a decent window for us, especially with the extra fire power up front. However I sit here absolutely aghast that with all the time the powers that be at our club had, they failed to make the most important and vital transfer deal this January – signing a good quality central defender.

I understand the argument regarding not being fleeced by selling clubs and being patient for the right deal, but lets stop being all cotton candy and glass half full for a minute. If we were really going to challenge Arsenal or Liverpool for 5th place then we needed a defender. We had time to scout a fair number of suitable candidates that would have been available at the right price for both NUFC and the seller.We had more than enough time to get a deal over the line.

Now we are left with Mike Williamson and Fabricio Coloccini being the only two fit recognised central defenders at our club and if the latter in particular gets injured we are in trouble. Refer to the Norwich game for an example. I don’t buy this James Perch can do a good job when needed guff. I take my hat off to the lad, he is doing a fantastic job coming on as a defensive midfielder and I believe Alan Pardew has finally found the lad a role he can excel in here – but on almost every occasion he has represented us in the back four we have looked ropey and exposed.

We know Pardew does not like Kadar as a player. He has been fit for a couple of months now and played well for the reserves, but has been overlooked every time an opportunity came up in the back line, so that is not going to change. Don’t get me wrong, we are having an excellent season and if we stay injury free our players could be strutting their stuff in Europe next season. However, I’m only too aware of how fast heads begin to drop when we get a bad result or two thanks to square pegs being put in round holes when injuries strike.

I for one am delighted that we kept our best players and signed a goal machine, but it can only be seen as a huge failure to have not secured adequate cover for central defence going into the toughest period of the footballing calendar. If we qualify for Europe, our key players are more likely to want to stay whilst we are in a much stronger position to attract good footballers to the club in the summer. Add to that the exposure to new audiences and potential future revenue that brings into the club and it has to be concluded that we have taken a huge gamble by not securing that defender.

Lets just hope that gamble pays off…

About Shamrock

Like everyone here, support Newcastle United. Not the easiest side to feel good about at times, but it's our side!

114 thoughts on “January transfer window round up – a realist view!

  1. What a shame we cannot simply enjoy being in the position we are in. So many fans on here seem to be so wise with hindsight. We all champion Tiote, Cabaye and Demba Ba now however when they were signed not many people on here were happy.
    We have done the big signings and panic buying before Marcelino, Boumsong, Viana, Luque, M.Owen, Viduka, Femi Martins we could go on.
    Hey I think the people in charge of our great club could do a lot better in the PR stakes but whether we like them or not at least the team is up there challenging the likes of Arsenal, Chelsea and Liverpool and I doubt anyone on this site predicted that last August.
    One thing I do like Shamrock is the point you make about being in the same position next year with the African Nations again.


  2. I think Collo or Willo are more likely to get a red card, perhaps even retrospectively, than get injured.
    Not getting a CB isnt a gamble, its professional neglect.


  3. @gadga , hhhmmmm we also signed shearer tino colo … Could go on for big money and gonzolez kuqi campbell rush … Could go on for free , most fans exept freddys big spending all the time was bad but MA penny pinching is just as dangerous and mikey aint got us into europe yet ! Wouldent a nice mix of the two be better !


  4. I’m happy with the way things are going and especially these two strikers. We could have the best goalkeeper some of the best centre halves, the best midfield pair and the best striker pair in the league. The spine of our team could be immense! If there is a class CB that the club have lined up in the summer then maybe it just wasn’t worth getting someone like Mariappa in from the championship.


  5. excellent article Shamrock.

    The Best deal with Celtic was very strange, it seems Mike likes a gamble, not sure why tho, Best can’t be earning that much and will always be a decent cover player. Seems pointless letting him leave.

    Same goes for a defender, we had plenty time. We didnt need to spend millions. R Nelson or L Ridgewell would of been a good, cheap option and would be adequate cover for a couple of years.

    Not securing a covering defender could be the difference between finishing in Europe and not.


  6. They obviously have faith in the young players to do a job if something happens to either Colo or Williamson.

    You people were saying the EXACT SAME THING at the end of the summer transfer window when we failed to get a striker, and look how that situation has turned out. There was nobody decent enough available within our budget at the time, so we waited and got our man later. I think Pardew et al have earned a bit of trust back by now.

    There are still problems with Mike Ashley I agree (mainly treating fans with contempt), but tbh a lot of NUFC fans are ****ing idiots so I think he’s just given up caring. I would much rather this sustainable growth plan than the Freddy Shepherd route to bankruptcy anyday.


  7. Whinge whinge – jeez this blogs starting to sound like workys, we’re kin 5th – a point behind chelski and ahead of arse, bindippers and that’s without a CB pairing for a few games, no Ba, Tiote – cabaye suspended, HBA not picked, – S Taylor, Marveaux injured and having to play not good enough perch, raylor, Guthrie, Simmo, obertan

    ……. There’s no one as fickle as us fans


  8. Forget the fact that the clubs actually making a profit and not spent 100 million ala Liverpool or 40 million ala Arsenal or wasted 60 million on ****e like Chelsea ( sorest that mata blokes ok) 😉


  9. Taylor is expected to make a swifter recovery from soft tissue damage to his right shin sustained when he was caught by Stephen Warnock’s studs. Although eyebrows were raised that what seemed a wild lunge as the Villa left-back endeavoured to block Taylor’s shot went unpunished, the FA will not review the incident retrospectively as it it says it was an “on the ball” challenge……

    F.A are a complete joke


  10. Its good to see Fergy back too. If we do suffer an injury to Colo or Willo I’m sure Santon could deputise and Fergy or Raylor could drop in at LBack.


  11. Mark@87 , Again spoton but we are fans and would love the europa league MA is money hungry and the europa league isn’t worth big bucks and its lots of games so we would need a bigger squad not good news for mikey !
    Whatever way u paint it a push for europe with two ch is crazy and with the time we have had is neglect and offering best to celtic silly , a board driven by profit and money and how can’t people see that !


  12. The only hope we have is Pardieu & Kadar kiss & make up. We need a cb on bench. We’ve been after one since Sol was kicked out ❗


  13. Just hope the gamble about a centre half pays off. It could end up costing us a couple of million in league places or even worse a champions league place. 😯


  14. @stevep , woop I’m so pleased we got beaten of brighton because of our weak squad , woop I’m so gratefull to mikey boy for only signing players wene the deal is right and not when the need is there !
    But most of all now you have told me the club are making a profit I’m off to bed to sleep sound I’m so pleased I hope mikey invests that profit wisely mind !!
    Zzzzz 😉


  15. dont see the need for negativity im sure if we got desperate kadar or streete would get a chance, after alka isnt that what the youth and reserve teams are for, imo we didnt spend on a cb because we have 1 lined up for summer. Probably douglas. Wats the point in spending over the odds on a cover player when you can get a younger better player for free in 5 months, p.s hope we get after spurs and dnt sit back. If sum 1 mullers bale early on he will go into hiding, the little faggot. Step up perchino.


  16. Would be nice to see the FA retrospectively charge people for cheating like bale for diving like a pussy as well. Least a one match ban in my book, not as bad as a bad tackle but still pathetic.

    One match is all I ask…. 😀


  17. newkie… 1 match ban would be nice just miss our game. Dnt mind him playin though. We contained him at sjp, im sure obertan wil have him covered. Think we have enough to beat them tho.


  18. Alex-he had a woeful finish today so we can hope that he’ll be off form, in which case its not so bad him playing….Don’t think we’ll have enough to beat them though, if we had both Cabaye and Tiote we’d be in with a shout, but it’ll be very tough as it is.


  19. I know I’m late Shamrock but for what it’s worth, cracking article.

    I dont think you haven’t said anything which hasnt been mentioned before but you’ve summarised it nicely.

    Couldn’t agree more.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green