Physical or Committed ?

Mitrovic receives his standard card-per-game.
Mitrovic receives his standard card-per-game.
Just four games into the new season and it seems Newcastle are being branded as overly physical in games by a couple of managers, namely Monk and Wenger.

I suppose it makes a change from soft, and easy to beat and lacking in heart and desire, such was the lable of last season. Anyway I thought I would take a look at some stats from the last four games to see if these accusations are true.

Our first game saw us take on Southampton and we picked up 2 yellow cards and committed 9 fouls, we won 15 free kicks. Saints on the other hand collected 4 yellow cards committed 12 fouls and won 9 free kicks, so on the balance of play I would say we were the less physical on the day.

Our second game saw us take on Swansea where we picked up 1 yellow and a red card and committed 11 fouls and we won 13 free kicks. Swansea collected 2 yellows, one more than us and committed 8 fouls just 3 less than us and only won 9 free kicks. As for the red card for Janmaat, it was a pull back on Montero, hardly physical and we’ll see plenty of good right backs suffer at the hands of Montero this season, that much is for sure. I really can’t see much for Garry Monk to of complained about going by that set of stats.

Our third game was against Manchester united where we recieved 2 yellow cards, committed 11 fouls and won an impressive 19 free kicks. Manchester by comparison also got 2 yellows but committed 15 fouls, 4 more than us and won 11 free kicks. Again we were hardly the more aggressive side there.

Our last game was against Arsenal which is where the stats would have you believe it all went wrong. We all know Mitrovic got that quick red card for a studs up challenge, and it has divided opinion as to whether it was deserved or not. We also collected 6 yellows not helped by Arsenal players falling and rolling like a sniper had got them, despite miraculously getting up right as rain seconds after our player is booked. We committed 15 fouls and won 10 free kicks. Arsenal collected just 1 yellow despite the fact they carried out a fair few rash challenges themselves on the day. They also committed 8 fouls and won 15 free kicks . The general consensus seems to be that referee for the day Mariner had a bit of a mare in that he was inconsistent with his cards and free kicks and missed a certain penalty claim for Arsenal too. After the game Arsene Wenger accused the Newcastle players of being physical but even though the stats back that up, I would argue that the referee lost control was inconsistent so the true nature of the game was lost.

Overall I would say we aren’t particularly more physical than any other side out there. I just think sides are taken aback by our renewed committment which was sadly lacking last season in most if not all our playing staff. Such was the frustration of players last season when our form dipped, they ended up losing self control and discipline and we ended the season with a high tally of red and yellow cards respectively. I don’t see that frustration now, just a desire to not give up which is long over due. If other teams are upset because we no longer give up the ghost so quickly, then tough, I for one am glad we don’t intend to be this seasons whipping boys.

Do you think we are a dirty or overly physical side? Thoughts welcome as ever.


155 thoughts on “Physical or Committed ?

  1. Sharpy, yep, any of them three would improve us, though we mustn’t forget Cabs went on strike to force a move away and for me that ruled out any return. He found out the grass ain’t greener and now he’s at Palace.


  2. Kim – I didn’t say I would take Cabaye back, personally I can’t stand the little ****. But he’s a good player & the type of ball playing midfielder we need. I would love to get Shelvey but don’t see that happening at all.
    As for Toots slowing play down, maybe sometimes that can be a good thing?!. I think all to often we can seem rushed and the wrong pass is made, or the pass itself is ****e. The likes of Shelvey & Carrick seem to take their time with passes and can regularly make key passes from their position. Tiotes trouble is he doesn’t find the space to afford him that time & ultimately gets caught on the ball. But then he’s a ball winning midfielder rather than a playmaker.
    Anita is probably our best playmaker at the moment, and has started this season quite well, but I still don’t think he’s going to cut the physical side of the PL.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green