PLAYER RATINGS – Newcastle 1-1 Liverpool

Another positive result at St James’ Park today, as we earned a hard fought point against a supremely talented Liverpool side.

Here’s my thoughts and marks out of 10 for the starting 11 today:


Elliot – 7 – As ever made the odd big save when called upon and was sharp off his line to cut out Liverpool’s threat in behind. Could do little to stop Coutinho’s first half pile driver.

Yedlin – 8*- Didn’t get much chance to get forward, but put in one of his best defensive displays since arriving on Tyneside. Read the game well, got into their faces and barely gave Mane an inch all afternoon. Our best player today for me.

Lascelles – 7.5 – A strong display from the captain. Made a crucial first half block to deny Sturridge and led by example throughout. A committed and commanding performance.

Clark – 7 – Very nearly gifted Liverpool a second goal and was caught out for pace at times, but generally did a solid job alongside Lascelles to keep the visitors at bay.

Manquillo –  6 – Got drawn out of position on occasion in the first-half, allowing right-back Gomez to cross a little too easily. In the end though, he did a decent job against one of the Premier League’s top performing wingers Mohamed Salah considering he’d been thrown in at left back for the first time this season.

Shelvey – 6.5 – Allowed Coutinho to cut inside an score a little too easily for Liverpool’s goal, but was vital at the other end in setting up Joselu’s goal with defence splitting pass. Showed the odd sign of rustiness, but made a few great passes to turn defence into attack.

Merino – 7 – Risked the ball in some dangerous areas on the odd occasion in the first half, but got in their faces, carried the ball well and put in another huge effort.

Ritchie – 7 – Didn’t get a great deal of chances to get at Moreno down the right, but as ever with Ritchie, he put in a dogged display and never stopped working for the team.

Perez – 5 – Failed to have any real impact on the game. Didn’t get himself in good positions to latch onto Joselu’s flick ons and was chasing shadows all too often. Needs to offer more in the 10 role.

Atsu – 6 – Offered an outlet down the left and tried to make things happen when he got a chance, however his final product let him down at times.

Joselu – 7 – Managed to take his big chance today, albeit fortunately, and put in a big shift up top. Was isolated up top for the most part, but put himself about, won some flick ons and linked up the play nicely when he had runners around him.

(Fancy writing for us? Send any articles/ideas over to us at & we’ll get back to you!)

About Olly Hawkins

Olly has been a Junior Magpie from birth. As a season ticket holder and avid Newcastle United fan - he eats, sleeps and breathes all things NUFC.

One thought on “PLAYER RATINGS – Newcastle 1-1 Liverpool

  1. Hmmmm disagree with lots of these ratings. Perez was poor for sure but Elliot was strong. As was the entire defence. Clark made one mistake which wasn’t punished, I felt he earned that bit of luck. Shelvey looked confident the first half, ran out of steam a bit in the second but let’s remember this is a Liverpool side that rely’s on their attacking which is really strong. With exception of Joselu, merino and manquillo this was a side that played in the championship last season. What score would we have predicted if we had have played them last season? I think the team as a whole need a lot of credit for today’s result. Interested in discussing these ratings.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green