NUFC make move to sign French duo? – Top talents but a worrying sign for Rafa Benitez..

We are all desperate for good news on new signings and there are reports from Sky and ‘L’Equipe’ that we are now in talks to sign two highly rated French youngsters –  Lyon striker Myziane Maolida and PSG left back Stanley Nsoki.

Both are 19 and rated around £7m each and I have to say, I find the links a little baffling (and worrying) if they are indeed true.

They are promising players and well regarded in France but they just aren’t the profile of player we need, seeming a far cry from the type of signing Rafa Benitez is wanting to see us make this summer. 

Don’t get me wrong, signing players for the future is great, but we need players for TODAY.

We don’t have the luxury of spending our tiny budget on players who might come good – Rafa wants experienced and quality additions. Yes we need a left back and striker, but this feels like the board seeing pound signs and going for a player based on their ability to go up in value / sell on potential rather than what the manager wants or has asked for.

Rafa has insisted he needs experience, quality and PL know how – ironic that he gets told £8m may be ‘too much’ for Argentina’s LB Nicolas Tagliafico and the club take an age to activate Rondons release clause (which has now expired) but they’ll probably jump at the chance to snap up two highly rated Frenchman who the club probably think A) they’d make a killing off and B ) Benitez will be able to coach into being good enough eventually.
It’s a big risk and suggests the club have not learned, going back to Graham Carr style signings.
For every Cabaye there was a Cabella or Saivet. These type of signings should be the icing on the cake so to speak and nice options to strengthen a strong squad after your main business is done – they should not be the mains signings. Especially up front, potentially signing a 19 year old striker with no PL experience would sum this summer up for NUFC.
It’s about time Newcastle stopped gambling with events on and off the field and that includes trying to unearth gems rather than buying players we actually need.

(Fancy writing for us? Send any articles/ideas over to us at & we’ll get back to you!)

About Simon Riddlesden

Lifelong Newcastle United fan and East Stand season ticket holder. Observations from a supporter who has followed NUFC during Champions League participation and through relegation, taking me from Milan to Scunthorpe.

3 thoughts on “NUFC make move to sign French duo? – Top talents but a worrying sign for Rafa Benitez..

  1. I would be very happy with these 2. 19/20 isn’t too young these days and besides many players come into the PL with no experience. Much rather these 2 than Rondon or another Joselu.


  2. I don’t often if ever defend Ashley et all, but this outcry by fans of all clubs to keep spending huge amounts of money on big name has beens is becoming silly.
    We really need Rafa to now buck this trend and produce a top half finish with a team he has build, and not bought like Mourinho, Guardiola whos budgets we cannot match.


  3. I really find the negativity of this blog quite frustrating, we need talented players, these guys meet this criteria and 19/20 is no reason why they shouldn’t start in the PL.

    I know Rafa is a good manager but he is a not lose manager rather than free flow attack, so we could spend a lot on top striker but system won’t get best out of them probably, ie another Mitro.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green