If Bruce is sticking with a 5-3-2, this is the side I want to see vs Aston Villa – 4 changes

There were some positives to take from Sunday, but there was also a few awful displays and gaping holes in a side that were cut open all too easily by West Ham.

We need a couple of new signings – we’re crying out for a midfield enforcer and ball-playing centre back with pace – however we must also make a few changes at Aston Villa this Saturday if we want to avoid a similar story.

Providing Bruce sticks with the 5-3-2 formation he’s stuck by in recent months, here’s the side I’d like to see us go with at Villa Park:

(5-3-2): Woodman – Murphy, Schar, Lascelles, Fernandez, Lewis – Hayden, Willock, Almiron – Saint-Maximin, Wilson.

OUTKrafth, Clark, Ritchie, Shelvey

IN Schar, Lascelles, Lewis, Willock

Will Bruce drop Ritchie and Shelvey? Probably not, but both had shocking second halves on Sunday and will have their work cut out against Villa – a team with a combative midfield and creative players capable of doing real damage in Buendia, Bailey and Bertrand Traore.

Lewis struggled last season, but he bagged a couple of assists in pre-season and could have a Murphy-esque breakthrough season if given game time and the confidence to kick on in a system that should suit him. He’s also a great athlete capable of getting up and down the line and far quicker than Ritchie.

For all of Ritchie’s effort, he’s not a defender and got caught out far too often against West Ham. As for Shelvey, he started brightly but soon played with his head down, hands on hips and disappeared from the game just when we’d want our ‘captain’ to step up.

Providing he can get a good week of training under his belt after a bit-part pre-season at Arsenal, Joe Willock should walk into this team. His energy, ability to carry the ball from deep – something we were over reliant on ASM to do on Sunday – and goal threat is priceless in a midfield that often looked a little one-paced before his arrival.

Lascelles should also come back in on Saturday. Some don’t rate the skipper, but we nearly always look less organised when he’s not playing. I’d bring him back in for Krafth – who tries but just isn’t a centre-back or Premier League player.

As for Clark, he often does a job with minimal fuss, yet in this system his lack of pace or ability on the ball was there for all to see on Sunday. As a result, Schar could come in to give us that air of calm in possession, with his ability to pick passes from deep able to make up for what we lose without Shelvey.

I’m aware that this means three changes to the five-man defence that started on against West Ham, but Newcastle conceded double the number of big chances than any other team over the opening Premier League weekend. Do that again on Saturday and it’ll be another defeat.

How would you like to see us set up this weekend?

About Olly Hawkins

Olly has been a Junior Magpie from birth. As a season ticket holder and avid Newcastle United fan - he eats, sleeps and breathes all things NUFC.

3 thoughts on “If Bruce is sticking with a 5-3-2, this is the side I want to see vs Aston Villa – 4 changes

  1. It does seem trendy to hammer Shelvey but the evidence, watched by 50,000 plus live and probably hundreds of thousands on TV suggests he did not have a shocking second half, as you claim.
    He was certainly no worse than say 7 or 8 of the other players on the pitch, and while he didn’t shine it was no shocker.
    Ritchie went AWOL quite a bit so I won’t jump to his defence.
    If you want to take people off for not performing, how about the number of times ASM lost the ball in our half by just turning straight into opposition players, or by miscontrolling, or by just falling over? Using your logic Ritchie’s cross getting the assist for Murphy’s goal should forgive him all other sins.
    You need to get over the 2 dribbles ASM got away with and concentrate more on the 20 he didn’t.
    I’d drag Murphy straight out of there – now that was a shocker.


  2. I get the impression with some that Bruce couldn’t win no matter what he did.
    For the last 2 season’s he’s been slagged off for playing 7 at the back and not playing attacking football.
    Now he shows us possibly the most attacking game we’ve seen in a decade he gets slated for having a hopeless defence.
    I seem to remember both him and Rafa saying that we don’t have the players to play on the front foot, but while the fans praised Rafa for his foresight they had a go at Bruce for being tactically inept.
    Perhaps we don’t have the players but Bruce has allowed himself to be harangued into it by the fans. I hope we manage to bring in a couple of quick defenders before the windows slams shut.
    Why does the transfer window always “slam” shut?


  3. Think you are being over the top with your criticism of shelvey ollie can’t remember him giving the ball away are losing it on a dangerous area like the superstar ASM did that led yo West ham’s second goal personally think if Bruce played one of hayden or longstaff sitting alongside shelvey midfield might not get exposed as much


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green