NUFC player ratings vs Man Utd – One 8, three 7’s, several 5’s and 6’s + one 4

Another frustrating day filled with avoidable goals, as Cristiano Ronaldo scored either side of a Javier Manquillo equaliser in a 4-1 win for Manchester United.

Here’s our marks out of 10 and comments on each player involved:


Woodman – 4 – Might struggle to keep his place after this one. Parried a deflected Greenwood strike straight to Ronaldo and could’ve also done better with CR7’s second, with his low shot going straight through Woodman’s legs.

Manquillo – 7.5 – Easily our best defender today. Caught out slightly for their second, but took his goal very well, kept Sancho extremely quiet and, at times, combined brilliantly with Almiron down that right. We may have conceded four today, but we looked a little bit more compact from a defensive point of view with him back in the side.

Hayden – 5 – Got caught out for Ronaldo’s all important second, allowing the striker to ghost in between himself and Manquillo before firing past Woodman.

Lascelles – 5 – A few important interceptions, but got nowhere near Lingard for their fourth. Tempted to mark him down one for the way he ran after Ronaldo for his shirt just seconds after the full time whistle…

Clark – 5 – Came in for Schar and didn’t do a great deal wrong in the first half. Sadly, the second 45 was a different story and he rarely got close to those in red shirts.

Ritchie – 6 – Got in their faces and tried to get up the line to offer an out-ball, however there was rarely anyone to hit in the box. Better defensively and did OK against Greenwood, but corners were mixed and a few of his efforts from range were speculative at best.

S Longstaff – 7 – I actually thought he played well today and looked more like the player that burst onto the scene under Benitez. Kept it simple, worked hard, got in the faces of Man Utd midfield constantly looking to create and looked more composed on the ball. Much better.

Willock – 6 – Looks a little bit rusty, which makes sense given his lack of pre-season training. Blazed one decent chance over the bar after dispossessing Fernandes in the opposition box, but got stuck in and didn’t stop running – even if he did fizzle out of the game in the 2nd half.

Almiron – 8* – The best player on the field from a Newcastle United perspective. He worked tirelessly to protect Manquillo – who was up against Shaw and Sancho – filled in well to break up the play in midfield and used his pace and energy to carry the ball up with pitch at the other end. Also played a big role in our goal, winning the ball back in a dangerous area before ASM set up Manquillo.

Saint-Maximin – 7 – Our biggest threat on the break, skipping past Pogba and Matic on a few occasions to run straight at Man Utd’s back line. He was sometimes a little wasteful, delaying his final pass or running into trouble, but he kept going, was our main out-ball and timed his pass perfectly to set up Manquillo’s equaliser.

Joelinton – 6 – Often filled in down the left-hand side, but didn’t offer Ritchie as much protection as Almiron did for Manquillo down the other side. Won plenty in the air and was a handful at times, wriggling free on a few occasions to get shots off.


Murphy – N/A – The odd attempt to break forward, but few touches in truth during his 15 minutes on the pitch.

Hendrick – N/A – Replaced Willock for the final five minutes.

Lewis – N/A – Replaced Clark with five minutes remaining.

About Olly Hawkins

Olly has been a Junior Magpie from birth. As a season ticket holder and avid Newcastle United fan - he eats, sleeps and breathes all things NUFC.

7 thoughts on “NUFC player ratings vs Man Utd – One 8, three 7’s, several 5’s and 6’s + one 4

  1. Ageing defence with no pace, lack of real bite in midfield and inadequate cover up front will cost us this season, Woodman has his work cut out with that lot in front of him, Swansea we’re obviously better drilled defensively than us, but he was poor for the first goal.


  2. I was pleasantly surprised we scored a goal and even had a few more legitimate chances. But FFS we basically played 9 back on defense and still conceded 4 goals. Now Leeds coming and they must be salivating at the sight of how this team defends.


  3. But Cabbage will be drilling this team “meticulously” all week in preparation for Friday night. Unless he is off to Portugal again to bask in the sun while the club drowns in his p!ss…


  4. Joseph:
    Swansea we’re obviously better drilled defensively than us, but he was poor for the first goal.

    They were also in a lower division.


  5. ” Tempted to mark him (Lascelles) down one for the way he ran after Ronaldo for his shirt just seconds after the full time whistle”
    You should mark him up – that was the fastest he moved all day.


  6. I thought we actually played very well against a team of global all-stars. We got forward a lot and as ever, just missed the ability to finish. That’s not to say that Man U couldn’t just step it up at any time, had we actually found the back of the net.
    I’ve supported the Toon for half a century but had a smile on my face when Ronaldo scored, again when Bruno scored that corker from outside the box, and again when Lindgard got on the end of that classy move inside our box.
    Sometimes you just have to enjoy the football.


  7. BykerBill:
    I couldn’t have put it better!
    Swansea are a Championship side, and unless we get our defence in order that’s where we will end up next season.!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Question   Razz  Sad   Evil  Exclaim  Smile  Redface  Biggrin  Surprised  Eek   Confused   Cool  LOL   Mad   Twisted  Rolleyes   Wink  Idea  Arrow  Neutral  Cry   Mr. Green