Italy legend tells Sandro Tonali to reject Man Utd and Arsenal for Newcastle stay

It seems that every other story this week has been about Sandro Tonali as the Italian’s Newcastle United future becomes a hot topic of debate.

Away from the relentless newspaper claptrap, fans are now starting to question Tonali’s loyalty to the club, especially after playing such a big role in Italy’s win over Northern Ireland last night.

Sandro Tonali sat out the Tyne-Wear derby on Sunday after picking up a knock against Barcelona. The fact that there have been four days between Sunday and Tonali’s goal-scoring performance for Italy doesn’t seem to matter to some people, and the Italian is being berated online for having the audacity to heal.

It has since been reported that Tonali wanted to play on Sunday, but Newcastle’s medical team advised against it. But with the backdrop of relentless talk surrounding a potential summer exit, fans have been in no mood to give him the benefit of the doubt.

Materazzi urges Tonali to think before he jumps

Clearly, the relationship between Tonali and the fans is strained right now, but former Italy international Marco Materazzi has urged Tonali to remember what Newcastle did for him before deciding on his next step.

The ex-Inter defender told Hajper (via GOAL) that Tonali must not forget that Newcastle backed him at his lowest point, and that loyalty and ‘legacy’ should count for something.

Sandro Tonali can play in any team in Italy and England but he has to decide if he wants to stay at Newcastle United because they believed in him.

“The city and the fans and the club believed in him and stuck by him.

He has to think about that too, not just whether he could play for Arsenal, Liverpool or Manchester United.

“I would like him to stay at Newcastle and build his legacy.”

What is ‘loyalty’ in football anyway?

It makes a refreshing change having that kind of voice coming from Italy, as the general feeling we get is that Italians are practically demanding he return to their shores. Tonali has been linked with a return to Serie A pretty much since the plan that brought him to Tyneside touched down at Newcastle Airport.

Whether or not Tonali feels he’s repaid that debt remains to be seen, but it’s a leap to expect ‘loyalty’ from footballers.

Loyalty amongst footballers is a funny one to contemplate. As much as Newcastle have done for Tonali and how much the club, the city and the fans supported him during his 10-month ban, he, and every other player, is just here to do a job. They have no ties to the club, especially not ones as deep as fans have.  You may love your job, but if someone comes along and offers you a shedload more money to do the same thing, you’re going to at least be tempted.

It’s very rare that you get a case like Bruno Guimaraes, who has become an adopted Geordie. It’s magical when it happens, but 90% of the time, players will just follow the money. It’s a sad reality that we as fans have to deal with. We get attached to players, but when they go, we will find another to attach ourselves to. The pain will be short-lived.

About Ash Harrison

Ash Harrison, hailing from the picturesque city of Durham, proudly serves as a Football Writer at NUFC Blog, a role he has embraced since October 2023. His dedication to Newcastle United is not just professional; it's a lifelong passion. Before joining NUFC Blog, Ash honed his craft as a writer at NUFCFEED, Geordie Boot Boys and Vital Football.

8 thoughts on “Italy legend tells Sandro Tonali to reject Man Utd and Arsenal for Newcastle stay

  1. I think he is a great player; I also think he has no business being in Newcastle, he is a Milan boy through and through; but nobody in Italy can afford him (the usual EPL suspects can though).
    It would be great for him to stay. Would £80k – £100k compensate for his jumping ship?

      (Quote)

  2. “I would like him to stay at Newcastle and build his legacy.”
    How refreshing is that?
    Chelsea paid £115 mil for Moisés Caicedo, Tonali is easily as good, so if the cartel clubs want him,, pay his worth…

      (Quote)

  3. £150 million to the Sceptic 6, £120 million to anyone else (a sceptic 6 tax of £30 million)
    Would prefer he stayed though.

      (Quote)

  4. Sorry but if his agent could lie when we bought him, there are no surprises for me. The only person Sandro is loyal to is his agent and himself. The Derby game would not show case his talent and he could have been injured. Hence the need to bail out for the Italian show. I feel he’s changed since marriage and baby, maybe more responsibilities and a wife with expensive taste and ” baby showers”.! Whereas Bruno’s family were born in Newcastle, Tonali chose the ” posh ” London clinic. Says it all to me and just don’t trust him now. I’d sell him rather than have another Isak. Plus Karma never forgets.

      (Quote)

  5. Ash!! Until you said ‘Clearly, the relationship between Tonali and the fans is strained right now’ I had a certain amount of respect! Would you please develop the moment when the relationship became strained?

      (Quote)

  6. With the current state of play at Newcastle and likely no European football.. I think Sandro is entitled to leave for pastures new ..only Bayern the two Spanish scammers can afford him .. don’t think they will sell him to Man Utd. Etc unless it’s £120 million .. he will stay maybe new contract ?

      (Quote)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *